The buildings
Three Pinner estates and the changes their appraisals warn about
Each appraisal below was adopted in December 2009 and describes its estate as it was then. Read them as Harrow’s account of what can erode each estate’s character, not as a list of what will be approved.
The 1935 Pinnerwood Park brochure showed 15 house designs, from three-bedroom semi-detached to four-bedroom detached houses. Its appraisal records demand to extend them significantly at the rear, especially for more bedrooms, and warns that extensions not carefully considered create large expanses of extra bulk, while large ones compromise the garden setting. Where a semi-detached pair is ‘H’ shaped, owners commonly want to square off the rear. Some internal porches were enclosed with conservatory-type structures before the Article 4 direction; the appraisal says these detract from the original form and that the approach is unlikely to be supported in future.
Harrow: Pinnerwood Park Estate Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Strategy, adopted December 2009 (PDF)
At West Towers, the appraisal says dormers disrupt the clean lines of the shallow-pitched roofs and often the symmetry of semi-detached pairs, and that rooflights facing the street clutter the handmade clay tiles; at the rear they should be limited to a conservation style. Enclosing a recessed porch removes the intended depth of the doorway. Replacement windows often fail to copy the delicate leaded lights, and plastic ones are often much flatter in profile than the original timber. Side extensions, rare originally, one by one give a terraced feel, and concrete tiles add a dull, bland appearance to the roofscape.
Harrow: West Towers Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Strategy, adopted December 2009 (PDF)
Pinner Hill’s appraisal lists pressure for large extensions, including two-storey side and rear ones, and new buildings such as garages and large outbuildings, and says swimming pools reduce the gardens’ soft landscaping and the permeability of the land. In 2009 Harrow said it would consider an Article 4 direction on outbuildings. The 2009 Pinner SPD said that, as Green Belt over most of the estate restricts development, how far its houses can be extended is limited, creating a linked pressure to demolish part of a house and rebuild it to enlarge rooms; it relied on national guidance since replaced.
Harrow: Pinner Hill Estate Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Strategy, adopted December 2009 (PDF) · Harrow: Pinner Conservation Areas Supplementary Planning Document, adopted December 2009 (PDF)